Criterion Collection’s Letter Never Sent | Blu-ray Review

Bergman and Nykvist, Bertolucci and Storaro, Welles and Toland; the history of cinema is replete with great partnerships between directors and cinematographers. Through potent mixtures of chemistry and vision, these collaborations created works of iconic visual style, endowing the world with a lexicon of cinematic reference. Films like The Seventh Seal, The Last Emperor and Citizen Kane are so deeply entrenched in the canon they can usually be identified from one mere frame. While not as well known to westerners, director Mikhail Kalatozov and cameraman Sergei Urusevsky comprised an equally impressive artistic symbiosis in the Soviet Union during the early years of the cold war.

Hopefully Kalatozov and Urusevsky’s days of obscurity will come to an end with Criterion’s stunning blu-ray edition of Letter Never Sent, a chilling adventure from 1960 built from the whole cloth of nihilist nightmares. Like Russian dolls, the film presents reflections of Man’s relationship with the natural world in strata that lead ever deeper into the primal. Soviet society is on the verge of a historic technological breakthrough, but the means of achieving it lay buried deep in Mother Earth, and she does not dispense her spoils easily. As a small band of geologists will discover, the race to conquer the unknowns of outer space is infused with irony; for within the Soviet Union’s own borders exists a realm as untamed and remote as the moons of Saturn, and equally perilous.

Four Soviet scientists are dispatched to an unpopulated, sketchily charted region of Siberia in search of a long rumored lode of diamonds; a rich vein the Kremlin hopes will pay for its ambitious space program. The expedition is led by Sabinin (Innokenti Smoktunovsky), a laconic explorer of steely resolve who has attempted this search before only to come up empty. Accompanying him are the brawny Sergei (Yevgeny Urbansky) and a soon to be married couple: enthusiastic young Andrei (Vasili Livanov) and the beautiful Tanya (Tatyana Samoilova), who are head-over-heels in love. The first half of the film is devoted to the party’s trudge into the forbidding taiga, where weeks of rough living and back-breaking labor await them. But just as it appears the intrepid band will be rewarded for their efforts, a raging forest fire threatens to engulf them. With acres of towering spruce igniting like tinder, Sabinin and his associates realize that survival will require a herculean and heroic fight, a fight that must be successful to insure Russia’s reach for the stars.

Criterion’s previous Kalatozov/Urushevsky release – 1957’s The Cranes are Flying – was a spectacular showcase for the pair’s visual wizardry and Letter Never Sent continues their tradition of exquisite imagery. Gone are the complex, highly coordinated long takes involving thousands of extras that made Cranes such a bravura piece of filmmaking. Letter Never Sent is a more personal and philosophical work, although it too eventually radiates into grandiose scale. The film’s sudden shifting from internal monologue to a natural world gone mad is shocking and stunning, like the intrusion of a terrifying dream on quiet meditation. Urushevsky’s camera captures the brutal beauty of the smoldering taiga with stark compositions reminiscent of Ansel Adams’ brooding vistas of Yosemite. His rock steady handheld from Cranes is equally impressive here, tracking the exhausted explorers over miles of rugged terrain with the precision of motion control.

The script is neither film’s strong suit, and in its later reels Letter Never Sent occasionally devolves into that sappy patriotic melodrama common in Mosfilm productions. But Sabinin’s messianic upgrading to hero status is made more palatable by Kalatazov’s imaginative staging of the film’s penultimate scenes. Set on an eerie ice floe, Letter Never Sent’s coda grafts the imagery of Alexander Nevsky with the Crucifixion in yet another thinly veiled biblical metaphor; just as migrating birds symbolized the souls of war dead in The Cranes are Flying. Soviet censors were ever vigilant for decadent capitalistic messaging but Kalatazov’s New Testament allusions, while decidedly unsubtle, seem to have sailed right over their heads.

Disc Review

Criterion has delivered a disc worthy of Sergei Urusevky’s images, with sharpness and cleanliness the order of the day. Working extensively with graduated neutral density filters, Urusevsky kept the sky from burning out while creating an effective foreshadowing of the desperate times that awaited our heroes. The transfer retains the glistening, hallucinogenic edge of the original photography while rendering a full palette of tones. Urusevshy made clever use of colored filters as well and as the scientists probe deeper into the wilderness, foliage takes on a crisp pale tonality that seems unearthly. The original aspect of 1.33:1 is maintained, although most viewers will wish the filmmakers had opted for a wider frame; Letter Never Sent’s forbidding Siberian tableaux scream for 1.85.

The audio is presented in the original mono, and is free of noisy distractions – unless one counts Nikolai Kryukov’s overblown score. The disc’s recording is sonically perfect, but the music’s frequent lapses into corniness make it seem like a track from a 1930s radio show on occasion.

A booklet featuring an essay by film scholar Dina Iordanova

This 16 page edition contains production credits and a selection of film stills. Iordanova’s essay is worthwhile reading as well, particularly to those unfamiliar with the work of Kalatozov and Urusevsky. Iordanova speaks with authority on the background of Letter Never Sent and the reaction of Russian audiences to its recent theatrical re-release.

Final Thoughts

Letter Never Sent is a film that manages to transcend an overbearing score and an underdeveloped script to deliver a cinematic experience that triumphs on sheer visual aesthetics. Despite enormous physical challenges, Kalatozov and Urusevsky created a nightmarish wilderness journey, pitting the resilience of the human spirit against nature’s dark and deadly forces. Its attempts at profound commentary may be lacking, but Letter Never Sent remains a marvelous and harrowing spectacle, and this hi-def offering is a worthy addition to any cinephile’s library. We can only hope that 1964’s I Am Cuba, considered by many to be Kalatozov and Urusevsky’s finest achievement, will one day get the deluxe Criterion treatment.