Connect with us

Disc Reviews

Heaven Knows What | Blu-ray Review


The story of how the directorial brothers Benny and Joshua Safdie found their muse and star, Arielle Holmes, for their latest feature seems like a shadowy tale from a gritty Craigslist missed connection. After Joshua and their producer Sebastian Bear-McClard spotted her on a subway platform while working undercover for research on an abandoned genre film, they approached her. A subsequent series of no call, no shows seemed like a dead end, but then Holmes reached out, admitting that she’d been homeless, out of touch and had recently attempted to take her own life and was just recently released from the hospital. Since then, her life has been transformed since Heaven Knows What became a festival hit, winning the C.I.C.A.E. Award in Venice and the Tokyo Grand Prix and Best Director prizes at the Tokyo International Film Festival. Riding a wave of critical acclaim despite its white knuckled edge, the film was picked up for substantial distribution by the Weinsteins’ Radius label and has finally arrived on home video.

Having dropped out of school at 15 to become a homeless heroin junky running the mean streets of New York City, Holmes’s tale of depravity and desperation struck the Safdie’s with a fascinating idea. They suggested she write her life’s story and that they should collaborate on a film adaptation of what would become her memoir, ‘Mad Love in New York City’, if she would agreed to star as a fictionalized version of herself. Ferociously abrasive in its raw depiction of the despair and delusions that come with serious addiction and still fearlessly divine in its authentic austerity, Heaven Knows What is the take-no-prisoners style cinematic result.

No less harrowing than Arielle’s real life tales of woe, the film sees her wildfire on screen equivalent, Harley, wandering the streets, scraping for change, shooting up and obsessing over her repulsively vile on again, off again junky boyfriend Ilya, who’s played with terrifying conviction by X-Men: First Class actor Caleb Landry Jones. Harley’s never ending crusade to score sees her befriending dealers and fellow street druggies alike, gleaning a habit obliged rapport with the ceaselessly chatty Mike (Buddy Duress) and garnering the unwanted attention of Skully (Necro). Real life addicts are roped into the film’s woozy underground texture of fast food bathrooms and concrete couches, bringing an additional layer of distressing authenticity, yet it’s Arielle’s sensationally devout debut performance that makes the film so gruesomely gut wrenching.

Tracking her delirious emotional roller-coaster in scrutinizing Cassavetes-style vérité close ups, cinematographer Sean Price Williams proves to be the behind the scenes all star. His invasive lens weaves in on the faces of these tormented souls and around their unpredictable outbursts in lavishly loose long takes that accentuate the building tensions found within the frame. Locus on intimacy with an empathetic gaze, Williams explores the world-weariness within Harley’s eyes, a recurring rotation of terrified desperation and empty inebriation. No less important to the film’s aesthetic success is a remarkable soundtrack delicately layered with Isao Tomita’s electro renditions of famed Claude Debussy compositions. Imbuing the gritty urban landscape with a sense of sci-fi, Tomita’s pulsing synthesizers occasionally overtake all diegetic sound, amplifying the intensity of each increasingly frantic situation by aurally escaping to an otherworldly soundscape.

It’s no surprise then, that Heaven Knows What becomes a caustic experience in what it takes to escape the horrors of existence in a cyclic environment of addiction. In the Safdie’s smack-addled world of dependence and dereliction, love is as much an iconoclastic phenomenon as heroin use, both yielding cataclysmic results in the face of desperation. Taking inspiration from drug culture classics like Kids and The Panic in Needle Park while portraying something altogether perversely original in its depiction of corporate America as neglectful homeless shelter, the Safdie’s latest film embraces the consternation of living on the streets to portray these forgotten souls with an emotionally overwhelming sense of the real. Such an open-hearted, rawly bellicose realization of addiction has only been graced on celluloid but a handful of times, making the Safdie’s film a new exemplar of narcotic cinema for the ages.

Disc Review:

Sean Price Williams’ jaw droppingly gorgeous streetwise cinematography looks outstanding in HD, though the complimentary stereo track is comparably underwhelming. Where Isao Tomita’s beautifully manic synth soundtrack should swell to an earsplitting volume in contrast with the continuous dialog, it just doesn’t reach the spectral depth one might expect, especially in the low end.

Deleted Scenes
Most scenes left on the cutting room floor feel like necessary omissions, but that’s not necessarily the case with Heaven Knows What, as these four scenes, featuring additional encounters with Skully and Mike feel very of the film, almost missing in a way. Thankfully they are included here. 10 min

A Hot Two Weeks – The Making of Heaven Knows What
Directed by Simon Hacker, this behind the scenes look at the film features revealing interviews with Arielle, the Safdies and most heartbreaking, footage of the real Ilya on set during the shoot. This is a must watch. 17 min

Ariel Pink Music Video
As one of two original composers of some of the music in Heaven Knows What, this music video is comprised of cellphone footage taken in various bathrooms around NYC. I’m curious how this one made it through the cracks and on to the final product.

Final Thoughts:

Heaven Knows What is certainly not for everyone, but it will be remembered as an underground classic for its raw depiction of addiction and desperation on the streets of New York City, as well as for its daring romance with the realities of such situations, blurring the lines between fact and fiction with explosive results. Fans should have no reservations about picking this one up, despite its underwhelming audio performance.

Film Review: ★★★★½/☆☆☆☆☆
Disc Review:       ★★★/☆☆☆☆☆

Click to comment

More in Disc Reviews

To Top