Connect with us
Abu Bakr Shawky Yomeddine Review

Reviews

Yomeddine | Review

Yomeddine | Review

Natural Selection: Shawky Shackled by Straight Story

 

Yomeddine Abu Bakr Shawky PosterTackling notions of identity in both a figurative and transfigurative sense, Yomeddine teeters ever so lightly into fable terrain with a spirit akin to Miracle in Milan (1951) and proportionally Tod Browning’s Freaks. The antithesis of throw the baby out bleakness of a Bahman Ghobadi’s Turtles Can Fly, under the guise of the roadtrip buddy comedy (donkey is the favored mode of transportation here), we could coin Abu Bakr Shawky‘s feature debut has “hopeful” miserablism, a sincere, well-intention film with an attached quasi cathartic denounement that is simply too rough around-the-edges, formulaic to elicit any kind of emotion response, and cuffed by an overbearing score.

Totally embracing the novel idea of casting leprosy as is, non-actor Rady Gamal as Beshay and Ahmed Abdelhafiz known as a child without an identity but fly-by pseudonyms (the name Obama does stick), are thankfully introduced with what is a pre-established relationship. Doing away with the key motivation to our hero’s journey, based on the filmmaker’s 2008 short docu The Colony, and working with a title that translates as “Day of Judgement,” the idea of orphans is doubled here with this pairing. Despite the age discrepancy, it’s a friendship that painstakingly evolves into something a bit more symbolic, perhaps the treasure to be found on garbage mountain is human connection.

The limited range of the key actor is apparent once the novelty of casting in the image of the character wears thin, scenes feel forced and lack the naturalism or the addition of a certain docu-realism aesthetic would have added more depth or better serve sequences that are short in length. While the film does look handsome in parts, Shawky works hard at adding commentary on beauty as unflinching, bureaucracy woes and the Egyptian society of the past as reflected today, but these ideas come across as undernourished.

Look for comparisons to be made with a pair of David Lynch’s films in The Elephant Man (facial deformity) and The Straight Story (slow trek with handouts), but for this you-don’t-have-to-travel far to find a family narrative to have worked, perhaps contextually reconstituted families deserve more than sugar-coated treatment.

Reviewed on May 9th at the 2018 Cannes Film Festival – Competition. 93 Minutes

★/☆☆☆☆☆

Eric Lavallée is the founder, CEO, editor-in-chief, film journalist and critic at IONCINEMA.com (founded in 2000). Eric is a regular at Sundance, Cannes and TIFF. He has a BFA in Film Studies at the Mel Hoppenheim School of Cinema. In 2013 he served as a Narrative Competition Jury Member at the SXSW Film Festival. He was an associate producer on Mark Jackson's This Teacher (2018 LA Film Festival, 2018 BFI London). In 2022 he served as a New Flesh Comp for Best First Feature at the 2022 Fantasia Intl. Film Festival. Current top films for 2022 include Tár (Todd Field), All That Breathes (Shaunak Sen), Aftersun (Charlotte Wells).

Click to comment

More in Reviews

  • Alice Diop Saint Omer Review Alice Diop Saint Omer Review

    Reviews

    Saint Omer | Review

    By

    Parallel Mothers: Diop Explores Monstrousness and Motherhood in Provocative Courtroom Drama For her narrative feature debut...

  • Carla Simón's Alcarràs Review Carla Simón's Alcarràs Review

    Reviews

    Alcarràs | Review

    By

    Peach Be With You: Simon Harvests Bitter Reality in Solid, Steady Family Drama Returning to the...

  • Benoit Jacquot Par Coeurs Review Benoit Jacquot Par Coeurs Review

    Reviews

    Par Coeurs | Review

    By

    A Matter of Method: Jacquot Surveys the Techniques of Two French Titans in Conversational Doc “I’m...

  • Hirokazu Kore-eda Broker Review Hirokazu Kore-eda Broker Review

    Reviews

    Broker | Review

    By

    Be My Little Baby: Kore-eda Gets Weepy with Sentimental Adoption Drama Hirokazu Kore-eda, Japan’s esteemed purveyor...

  • Damien Chazelle Babylon Review Damien Chazelle Babylon Review

    Reviews

    Babylon [Video Review]

    By

    Something to Talkie About: Chazelle Swings Hard with Homage to Hollywood’s Unruly Infancy If there’s a...

To Top